Rankings · Methodology · Service quality · Planning

Major planning decisions overturned at appeal (24 months)

Lower is better. One of the measures behind the planning score; councils are listed by their rank on it alone, which is not their overall rank. The median of the 130 is 2.0%.

Refused decisions (including deemed refusals, where an appeal for non-determination was lodged) overturned at appeal, as a share of all major decisions plus non-determined applications, over the 24 months to September 2025 (appeals followed to June 2026, as the Planning Inspectorate decides them). A split appeal decision is not counted as overturned. Lower is better. Government designation measure (MHCLG tables P152 and P154); the designation threshold is 10% of major decisions and 10% of non-major decisions.

Major planning decisions overturned at appeal (24 months) by council
RankCouncilMajor planning decisions overturned at appeal (24 months)Type
=1Barking and Dagenham0.0%London borough
=1Barnet0.0%London borough
=1Blackburn with Darwen0.0%Unitary council
=1Blackpool0.0%Unitary council
=1Bolton0.0%Metropolitan borough
=1Brent0.0%London borough
=1Bury0.0%Metropolitan borough
=1Calderdale0.0%Metropolitan borough
=1Coventry0.0%Metropolitan borough
=1Cumberland0.0%Unitary council
=1Darlington0.0%Unitary council
=1Doncaster0.0%Metropolitan borough
=1Halton0.0%Unitary council
=1Haringey0.0%London borough
=1Harrow0.0%London borough
=1Kensington and Chelsea0.0%London borough
=1Kingston upon Hull, City of0.0%Unitary council
=1Knowsley0.0%Metropolitan borough
=1Lewisham0.0%London borough
=1Luton0.0%Unitary council
=1Merton0.0%London borough
=1Northumberland0.0%Unitary council
=1Nottingham0.0%Unitary council
=1Plymouth0.0%Unitary council
=1Portsmouth0.0%Unitary council
=1Redbridge0.0%London borough
=1Sheffield0.0%Metropolitan borough
=1Stoke-on-Trent0.0%Unitary council
=1Sunderland0.0%Metropolitan borough
=1Sutton0.0%London borough
=1Swindon0.0%Unitary council
=1Tameside0.0%Metropolitan borough
=1Waltham Forest0.0%London borough
=1Wirral0.0%Metropolitan borough
=1Wolverhampton0.0%Metropolitan borough
36Manchester0.5%Metropolitan borough
37Cheshire East0.7%Unitary council
38Bristol, City of0.8%Unitary council
39Wigan0.9%Metropolitan borough
40Westmorland and Furness1.0%Unitary council
41Shropshire1.1%Unitary council
42Medway1.1%Unitary council
43Bradford1.1%Metropolitan borough
44Leicester1.1%Unitary council
=45Derby1.4%Unitary council
=45Southwark1.4%London borough
=47Ealing1.4%London borough
=47North East Lincolnshire1.4%Unitary council
49Sandwell1.4%Metropolitan borough
50Kirklees1.5%Metropolitan borough
51Bath and North East Somerset1.5%Unitary council
52Brighton and Hove1.6%Unitary council
53Birmingham1.6%Metropolitan borough
=54Newcastle upon Tyne1.6%Metropolitan borough
=54Rochdale1.6%Metropolitan borough
=56Lambeth1.6%London borough
=56Salford1.6%Metropolitan borough
58Croydon1.7%London borough
59Hounslow1.7%London borough
60Westminster1.7%London borough
61Cheshire West and Chester1.7%Unitary council
62Sefton1.8%Metropolitan borough
63Wandsworth1.8%London borough
64Thurrock1.8%Unitary council
65Oldham2.0%Metropolitan borough
66Hillingdon2.0%London borough
67Wakefield2.1%Metropolitan borough
68Bracknell Forest2.1%Unitary council
69Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole2.1%Unitary council
=70North Northamptonshire2.2%Unitary council
=70North Tyneside2.2%Metropolitan borough
72Peterborough2.2%Unitary council
73Enfield2.3%London borough
74Liverpool2.3%Metropolitan borough
75St. Helens2.3%Metropolitan borough
76Milton Keynes2.3%Unitary council
77Leeds2.4%Metropolitan borough
=78Stockton-on-Tees2.6%Unitary council
=78York2.6%Unitary council
=80Trafford2.8%Metropolitan borough
=80Windsor and Maidenhead2.8%Unitary council
82Reading2.9%Unitary council
83East Riding of Yorkshire3.0%Unitary council
84Herefordshire, County of3.1%Unitary council
=85Hackney3.1%London borough
=85Hartlepool3.1%Unitary council
=87County Durham3.2%Unitary council
=87West Berkshire3.2%Unitary council
89Redcar and Cleveland3.5%Unitary council
90Gateshead3.6%Metropolitan borough
91Telford and Wrekin3.7%Unitary council
92Newham3.7%London borough
93Southampton3.8%Unitary council
94North Yorkshire3.9%Unitary council
95Rotherham4.3%Metropolitan borough
96Kingston upon Thames4.4%London borough
97Dorset4.5%Unitary council
=98Greenwich4.5%London borough
=98Islington4.5%London borough
=98South Gloucestershire4.5%Unitary council
101Central Bedfordshire4.7%Unitary council
102Cornwall4.8%Unitary council
103Southend-on-Sea4.9%Unitary council
104Bedford4.9%Unitary council
105Dudley5.0%Metropolitan borough
=106Camden5.1%London borough
=106Havering5.1%London borough
=106North Somerset5.1%Unitary council
109Buckinghamshire5.2%Unitary council
110Wokingham5.3%Unitary council
111Stockport5.4%Metropolitan borough
112Middlesbrough5.4%Unitary council
113Isle of Wight5.5%Unitary council
114Bromley5.6%London borough
115Warrington5.7%Unitary council
116Somerset5.7%Unitary council
117West Northamptonshire5.8%Unitary council
118Torbay6.3%Unitary council
=119Bexley6.5%London borough
=119North Lincolnshire6.5%Unitary council
121Barnsley6.5%Metropolitan borough
122Rutland6.7%Unitary council
123Hammersmith and Fulham6.9%London borough
=124Tower Hamlets7.1%London borough
=124Walsall7.2%Metropolitan borough
=124Slough7.7%Unitary council
=124Solihull9.1%Metropolitan borough
=124Richmond upon Thames9.5%London borough
=124Wiltshire11.7%Unitary council
=124South Tyneside16.0%Metropolitan borough

Period: 2023 Q4 to 2025 Q3. Source: MHCLG — Planning quality: decisions overturned at appeal (tables P152, P154). Councils with the same figure share a rank, and so do those beyond the 5th and 95th percentiles, because extreme values are capped before scoring (why). How we score

Shown but not ranked