Rankings · Methodology · Service quality · Planning

Non-major planning decisions overturned at appeal (24 months)

Lower is better. One of the measures behind the planning score; councils are listed by their rank on it alone, which is not their overall rank. The median of the 130 is 1.1%.

Refused decisions (including deemed refusals, where an appeal for non-determination was lodged) overturned at appeal, as a share of all non-major decisions plus non-determined applications, over the 24 months to September 2025 (appeals followed to June 2026, as the Planning Inspectorate decides them). A split appeal decision is not counted as overturned. Lower is better. Government designation measure (MHCLG tables P152 and P154); the designation threshold is 10% of major decisions and 10% of non-major decisions.

Non-major planning decisions overturned at appeal (24 months) by council
RankCouncilNon-major planning decisions overturned at appeal (24 months)Type
=1Knowsley0.2%Metropolitan borough
=1Cumberland0.2%Unitary council
=1Blackburn with Darwen0.2%Unitary council
=1Stockport0.2%Metropolitan borough
=1Peterborough0.2%Unitary council
=1Southwark0.3%London borough
=1Plymouth0.3%Unitary council
8Newcastle upon Tyne0.3%Metropolitan borough
9Darlington0.3%Unitary council
10St. Helens0.3%Metropolitan borough
11Salford0.4%Metropolitan borough
12Stockton-on-Tees0.4%Unitary council
13North Tyneside0.4%Metropolitan borough
14Walsall0.4%Metropolitan borough
15Sunderland0.4%Metropolitan borough
16Derby0.5%Unitary council
17Herefordshire, County of0.5%Unitary council
18Hartlepool0.5%Unitary council
19Doncaster0.6%Metropolitan borough
20Gateshead0.6%Metropolitan borough
21Wokingham0.6%Unitary council
22Bradford0.6%Metropolitan borough
23North East Lincolnshire0.6%Unitary council
24Medway0.6%Unitary council
25Halton0.6%Unitary council
26Rutland0.6%Unitary council
27Sheffield0.6%Metropolitan borough
28Milton Keynes0.7%Unitary council
29County Durham0.7%Unitary council
30Redcar and Cleveland0.7%Unitary council
31North Somerset0.7%Unitary council
32Sandwell0.7%Metropolitan borough
33Wiltshire0.7%Unitary council
34Bury0.7%Metropolitan borough
35Merton0.7%London borough
36Kirklees0.8%Metropolitan borough
37Islington0.8%London borough
38Rochdale0.8%Metropolitan borough
39Hammersmith and Fulham0.8%London borough
40East Riding of Yorkshire0.8%Unitary council
41Bolton0.8%Metropolitan borough
42York0.8%Unitary council
43Shropshire0.8%Unitary council
44Stoke-on-Trent0.8%Unitary council
45South Tyneside0.8%Metropolitan borough
46Bath and North East Somerset0.8%Unitary council
47Westmorland and Furness0.9%Unitary council
48Swindon0.9%Unitary council
49Leicester0.9%Unitary council
50Birmingham0.9%Metropolitan borough
51Somerset0.9%Unitary council
52Northumberland0.9%Unitary council
53Rotherham0.9%Metropolitan borough
54Sefton0.9%Metropolitan borough
55Newham1.0%London borough
56Wigan1.0%Metropolitan borough
57Wandsworth1.0%London borough
58Ealing1.0%London borough
59Westminster1.0%London borough
60Wirral1.0%Metropolitan borough
61Bexley1.0%London borough
62Calderdale1.0%Metropolitan borough
63Barnsley1.0%Metropolitan borough
64Dorset1.0%Unitary council
65Telford and Wrekin1.0%Unitary council
66Oldham1.1%Metropolitan borough
67Thurrock1.1%Unitary council
68Central Bedfordshire1.1%Unitary council
69Trafford1.1%Metropolitan borough
70Reading1.1%Unitary council
71Kingston upon Hull, City of1.1%Unitary council
72Southampton1.1%Unitary council
73Lewisham1.1%London borough
74North Yorkshire1.2%Unitary council
75Kensington and Chelsea1.2%London borough
76Buckinghamshire1.2%Unitary council
77Leeds1.2%Metropolitan borough
78West Berkshire1.2%Unitary council
79Redbridge1.2%London borough
80Bracknell Forest1.2%Unitary council
81Tower Hamlets1.2%London borough
82North Lincolnshire1.2%Unitary council
83West Northamptonshire1.2%Unitary council
84Brent1.2%London borough
85Haringey1.2%London borough
86Tameside1.3%Metropolitan borough
87Brighton and Hove1.3%Unitary council
88Sutton1.3%London borough
89Barking and Dagenham1.3%London borough
90Wolverhampton1.4%Metropolitan borough
91Isle of Wight1.4%Unitary council
92Wakefield1.4%Metropolitan borough
93Waltham Forest1.4%London borough
94Cheshire West and Chester1.4%Unitary council
95Blackpool1.4%Unitary council
96Enfield1.4%London borough
97Manchester1.5%Metropolitan borough
98Cornwall1.5%Unitary council
99Camden1.5%London borough
100Bedford1.6%Unitary council
101Windsor and Maidenhead1.7%Unitary council
102Lambeth1.7%London borough
103Middlesbrough1.7%Unitary council
104Cheshire East1.7%Unitary council
105Dudley1.7%Metropolitan borough
106Croydon1.7%London borough
107Southend-on-Sea1.7%Unitary council
108Solihull1.7%Metropolitan borough
109Portsmouth1.7%Unitary council
110Nottingham1.8%Unitary council
111Harrow1.8%London borough
112Richmond upon Thames1.9%London borough
113Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole1.9%Unitary council
114Coventry1.9%Metropolitan borough
115Bristol, City of1.9%Unitary council
116Slough2.0%Unitary council
117Hillingdon2.0%London borough
118Kingston upon Thames2.1%London borough
119Warrington2.2%Unitary council
120Liverpool2.2%Metropolitan borough
121North Northamptonshire2.2%Unitary council
122Barnet2.3%London borough
123South Gloucestershire2.4%Unitary council
=124Havering2.5%London borough
=124Hackney2.5%London borough
=124Bromley2.6%London borough
=124Greenwich2.9%London borough
=124Luton3.0%Unitary council
=124Torbay3.1%Unitary council
=124Hounslow4.0%London borough

Period: 2023 Q4 to 2025 Q3. Source: MHCLG — Planning quality: decisions overturned at appeal (tables P152, P154). Councils with the same figure share a rank, and so do those beyond the 5th and 95th percentiles, because extreme values are capped before scoring (why). How we score

Shown but not ranked