Rankings · Methodology · Service quality · Planning
Non-major planning decisions overturned at appeal (24 months)
Lower is better. One of the measures behind the planning score; councils are listed by their rank on it alone, which is not their overall rank. The median of the 130 is 1.1%.
Refused decisions (including deemed refusals, where an appeal for non-determination was lodged) overturned at appeal, as a share of all non-major decisions plus non-determined applications, over the 24 months to September 2025 (appeals followed to June 2026, as the Planning Inspectorate decides them). A split appeal decision is not counted as overturned. Lower is better. Government designation measure (MHCLG tables P152 and P154); the designation threshold is 10% of major decisions and 10% of non-major decisions.
| Rank | Council | Non-major planning decisions overturned at appeal (24 months) | Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| =1 | Knowsley | 0.2% | Metropolitan borough |
| =1 | Cumberland | 0.2% | Unitary council |
| =1 | Blackburn with Darwen | 0.2% | Unitary council |
| =1 | Stockport | 0.2% | Metropolitan borough |
| =1 | Peterborough | 0.2% | Unitary council |
| =1 | Southwark | 0.3% | London borough |
| =1 | Plymouth | 0.3% | Unitary council |
| 8 | Newcastle upon Tyne | 0.3% | Metropolitan borough |
| 9 | Darlington | 0.3% | Unitary council |
| 10 | St. Helens | 0.3% | Metropolitan borough |
| 11 | Salford | 0.4% | Metropolitan borough |
| 12 | Stockton-on-Tees | 0.4% | Unitary council |
| 13 | North Tyneside | 0.4% | Metropolitan borough |
| 14 | Walsall | 0.4% | Metropolitan borough |
| 15 | Sunderland | 0.4% | Metropolitan borough |
| 16 | Derby | 0.5% | Unitary council |
| 17 | Herefordshire, County of | 0.5% | Unitary council |
| 18 | Hartlepool | 0.5% | Unitary council |
| 19 | Doncaster | 0.6% | Metropolitan borough |
| 20 | Gateshead | 0.6% | Metropolitan borough |
| 21 | Wokingham | 0.6% | Unitary council |
| 22 | Bradford | 0.6% | Metropolitan borough |
| 23 | North East Lincolnshire | 0.6% | Unitary council |
| 24 | Medway | 0.6% | Unitary council |
| 25 | Halton | 0.6% | Unitary council |
| 26 | Rutland | 0.6% | Unitary council |
| 27 | Sheffield | 0.6% | Metropolitan borough |
| 28 | Milton Keynes | 0.7% | Unitary council |
| 29 | County Durham | 0.7% | Unitary council |
| 30 | Redcar and Cleveland | 0.7% | Unitary council |
| 31 | North Somerset | 0.7% | Unitary council |
| 32 | Sandwell | 0.7% | Metropolitan borough |
| 33 | Wiltshire | 0.7% | Unitary council |
| 34 | Bury | 0.7% | Metropolitan borough |
| 35 | Merton | 0.7% | London borough |
| 36 | Kirklees | 0.8% | Metropolitan borough |
| 37 | Islington | 0.8% | London borough |
| 38 | Rochdale | 0.8% | Metropolitan borough |
| 39 | Hammersmith and Fulham | 0.8% | London borough |
| 40 | East Riding of Yorkshire | 0.8% | Unitary council |
| 41 | Bolton | 0.8% | Metropolitan borough |
| 42 | York | 0.8% | Unitary council |
| 43 | Shropshire | 0.8% | Unitary council |
| 44 | Stoke-on-Trent | 0.8% | Unitary council |
| 45 | South Tyneside | 0.8% | Metropolitan borough |
| 46 | Bath and North East Somerset | 0.8% | Unitary council |
| 47 | Westmorland and Furness | 0.9% | Unitary council |
| 48 | Swindon | 0.9% | Unitary council |
| 49 | Leicester | 0.9% | Unitary council |
| 50 | Birmingham | 0.9% | Metropolitan borough |
| 51 | Somerset | 0.9% | Unitary council |
| 52 | Northumberland | 0.9% | Unitary council |
| 53 | Rotherham | 0.9% | Metropolitan borough |
| 54 | Sefton | 0.9% | Metropolitan borough |
| 55 | Newham | 1.0% | London borough |
| 56 | Wigan | 1.0% | Metropolitan borough |
| 57 | Wandsworth | 1.0% | London borough |
| 58 | Ealing | 1.0% | London borough |
| 59 | Westminster | 1.0% | London borough |
| 60 | Wirral | 1.0% | Metropolitan borough |
| 61 | Bexley | 1.0% | London borough |
| 62 | Calderdale | 1.0% | Metropolitan borough |
| 63 | Barnsley | 1.0% | Metropolitan borough |
| 64 | Dorset | 1.0% | Unitary council |
| 65 | Telford and Wrekin | 1.0% | Unitary council |
| 66 | Oldham | 1.1% | Metropolitan borough |
| 67 | Thurrock | 1.1% | Unitary council |
| 68 | Central Bedfordshire | 1.1% | Unitary council |
| 69 | Trafford | 1.1% | Metropolitan borough |
| 70 | Reading | 1.1% | Unitary council |
| 71 | Kingston upon Hull, City of | 1.1% | Unitary council |
| 72 | Southampton | 1.1% | Unitary council |
| 73 | Lewisham | 1.1% | London borough |
| 74 | North Yorkshire | 1.2% | Unitary council |
| 75 | Kensington and Chelsea | 1.2% | London borough |
| 76 | Buckinghamshire | 1.2% | Unitary council |
| 77 | Leeds | 1.2% | Metropolitan borough |
| 78 | West Berkshire | 1.2% | Unitary council |
| 79 | Redbridge | 1.2% | London borough |
| 80 | Bracknell Forest | 1.2% | Unitary council |
| 81 | Tower Hamlets | 1.2% | London borough |
| 82 | North Lincolnshire | 1.2% | Unitary council |
| 83 | West Northamptonshire | 1.2% | Unitary council |
| 84 | Brent | 1.2% | London borough |
| 85 | Haringey | 1.2% | London borough |
| 86 | Tameside | 1.3% | Metropolitan borough |
| 87 | Brighton and Hove | 1.3% | Unitary council |
| 88 | Sutton | 1.3% | London borough |
| 89 | Barking and Dagenham | 1.3% | London borough |
| 90 | Wolverhampton | 1.4% | Metropolitan borough |
| 91 | Isle of Wight | 1.4% | Unitary council |
| 92 | Wakefield | 1.4% | Metropolitan borough |
| 93 | Waltham Forest | 1.4% | London borough |
| 94 | Cheshire West and Chester | 1.4% | Unitary council |
| 95 | Blackpool | 1.4% | Unitary council |
| 96 | Enfield | 1.4% | London borough |
| 97 | Manchester | 1.5% | Metropolitan borough |
| 98 | Cornwall | 1.5% | Unitary council |
| 99 | Camden | 1.5% | London borough |
| 100 | Bedford | 1.6% | Unitary council |
| 101 | Windsor and Maidenhead | 1.7% | Unitary council |
| 102 | Lambeth | 1.7% | London borough |
| 103 | Middlesbrough | 1.7% | Unitary council |
| 104 | Cheshire East | 1.7% | Unitary council |
| 105 | Dudley | 1.7% | Metropolitan borough |
| 106 | Croydon | 1.7% | London borough |
| 107 | Southend-on-Sea | 1.7% | Unitary council |
| 108 | Solihull | 1.7% | Metropolitan borough |
| 109 | Portsmouth | 1.7% | Unitary council |
| 110 | Nottingham | 1.8% | Unitary council |
| 111 | Harrow | 1.8% | London borough |
| 112 | Richmond upon Thames | 1.9% | London borough |
| 113 | Bournemouth, Christchurch and Poole | 1.9% | Unitary council |
| 114 | Coventry | 1.9% | Metropolitan borough |
| 115 | Bristol, City of | 1.9% | Unitary council |
| 116 | Slough | 2.0% | Unitary council |
| 117 | Hillingdon | 2.0% | London borough |
| 118 | Kingston upon Thames | 2.1% | London borough |
| 119 | Warrington | 2.2% | Unitary council |
| 120 | Liverpool | 2.2% | Metropolitan borough |
| 121 | North Northamptonshire | 2.2% | Unitary council |
| 122 | Barnet | 2.3% | London borough |
| 123 | South Gloucestershire | 2.4% | Unitary council |
| =124 | Havering | 2.5% | London borough |
| =124 | Hackney | 2.5% | London borough |
| =124 | Bromley | 2.6% | London borough |
| =124 | Greenwich | 2.9% | London borough |
| =124 | Luton | 3.0% | Unitary council |
| =124 | Torbay | 3.1% | Unitary council |
| =124 | Hounslow | 4.0% | London borough |
Period: 2023 Q4 to 2025 Q3. Source: MHCLG — Planning quality: decisions overturned at appeal (tables P152, P154). Councils with the same figure share a rank, and so do those beyond the 5th and 95th percentiles, because extreme values are capped before scoring (why). How we score
Shown but not ranked
- City of London: 0.5%
- Isles of Scilly: 0.0%